I can never find eyeliner that will stay put for me so might as well try one originally designed for for performers of water ballet! Hallelujah! Finally something will stay on me longer than two hours. I put it on as soon as I got home from the store and spent the afternoon anxiously taking a peek every so often. It was still on! Granted, it didn’t stay on the waterline but it did make it through on the top lid. I got Matte Black but not I am tempted to go back and get a couple more colors like Pearly Brown 2L (golden brown sheen) and Star Black 1L (black sheen).